Why do this problem?
This problem begins with a simple paper fold, which leads
to an elegant result. Learners need to estimate lengths and
work accurately to construct and measure lines. Once they
have made a conjecture it can be justified with geometrical
arguments using angles and ratio. To prove the results
knowledge of similar triangles is needed, but the problem
could equally well be used as an introduction to the idea of
similarity.
Possible approach
Start by giving everyone a square of paper which they can
fold according to the diagrams. Encourage them to measure as
accurately as possible the two sections of the diagonal which
are formed. Collect together some measurements and ask what
the learners notice. What do they think would happen with
squares of different sizes? In order to collect a lot of data
in a short space of time, small groups could create different
sized squares and construct the lines and measure them,
sharing the results within their group.
Once a pattern has emerged bring the class together and ask
what they have found. Some learners will be convinced that
the relationship will always hold because they have tried it
with lots of examples, so there is a good opportunity to
discuss the distinction between demonstration and
mathematical proof.
In order to justify formally what they have noticed, learners
might find it useful to discuss what they know to be true,
and what a convincing argument shows to be true. This might
be for example that certain angles are equal.
Once pairs of equal angles are identified a route to a proof
becomes clearer.
The last part of the question asks about other quadrilaterals.
Some learners will be secure enough in the proof for squares to
attempt to prove or disprove the cases for other quadrilaterals
straight away without the need for accurate diagrams or
folding.
Key questions
What does it look like the folds are doing to the lines?
How could you verify what you think is true?
What other mathematics do you know that might be useful here?
Does this work for other quadrilaterals?
Possible extension
The problem
Take a Square II builds on these ideas and extends them
to different fractions of the line.
Possible support
The problem
Two Ladders could be used to investigate similar
triangles.