Why do this problem?
This problem gives learners the opportunity to use their
visualisation skills to investigate different paths over the
surface of a solid. Tackling the challenge of finding the
shortest path offers a chance to practise trigonometry, as
well as encouraging justification that there is no better
path than the one they find.
Possible approach
Start with a cube and investigate nets and paths.
How about an octahedron?
Next, ask everyone to imagine they were standing on the
surface of a dodecahedron. Ask what they can see if they are
standing on a face, on an edge, or on a vertex.
One way of introducing the idea of paths on the surface of
the dodecahedron is to have a model of a dodecahedron which
can be drawn on and then unfolded into its net.
Alternatively, the path could be drawn on a net and learners
will need to imagine how the parts of the path will meet up
when the net is folded up, to make sure it really is a closed
path.
The pictures of nets shown in the problem are not necessarily
the easiest nets to use to draw the path, so it is worth
drawing out discussion of what would be a good net to use in
order to aid visualisation.
Once everyone is happy with the idea of closed paths on the
surface of the dodecahedron, learners can start to create
their own paths and calculate the lengths. At each stage,
they should be challenging themselves to see whether there is
any way they can make the path shorter while still being able
to see every part of the planet's surface.
In order to compare answers within the classroom, it is
important for the class to decide how long one side of the
planet will be. This could be a good opportunity to discuss
the idea of working things out in terms of a unit length.
Key questions
How much of the planet's surface can I see if I stand at a
face, an edge, a vertex?
Is it easier to investigate this problem using some nets
rather than others?
Possible extension
The Dodecahedron provides an opportunity for further
exploration of paths on the surface.
Possible support
Use accurate scale drawing to calculate path lengths rather
than trigonometry.