Thank you to Julia from Langley Park School for
Girls, Bromley for this solution. Well done Julia.
For
to be a perfect cube,
must have
as a
factor so that the 2 in the denominator will cancel, leaving only
a perfect cube in the numerator.
For
to be a perfect 5th power,
must have
as a
factor for a similar reason to the one given above for
.
Similarly,
must have
as a factor for it to be a
perfect 7th power.
So we have now made
into a perfect cube, but it also needs
to be a perfect 5th and 7th power to satisfy the other conditions.
Thus
must be a multiple of 5 and 7 and therefore a
multiple of 35 (since 5 and 7 are relatively prime). The smallest
case of this is when
and
. So
is a
factor of
.
Continuing the same method and reasoning,
must be a
multiple of 3 and 7, and thus a multiple of 21. The smallest case
of this is when
and
. So
is another
factor of
.
Similarly
must be a multiple of 3 and 5, and thus a
multiple of 15. The smallest case of this is when
and
. So
is another factor of
.
Combining all the factors we conclude that:
.
is a perfect cube because
has a multiple of 3 in every power.
is a perfect 5th
power because
has a multiple
of 5 in every power.
is a perfect 7th power because
has a multiple of 7 in every power.
Pierce Geoghegan, Tarbert Comprehensive , Ireland and Ang Zhi
Ping, River Valley High, Singapore also sent excellent
solutions for this problem.