
Throughout history, different civilisations have had different
ways of representing numbers. Some of these systems seem strange
or complicated from our perspective. The ancient Egyptian ideas
about fractions are quite surprising. They wrote,for
example
(but with their numerals), these are $1/5$, $1/16$ and$1/429$ in
modern notation.
The ancient Egyptians had no notation for and probably no concept
of, say $2/7$ as a fraction. They didn't have any fraction that
we would write with a numerator greater than 1*. To them, "2
shared between 7" (i.e. $2/7$) was a problem, and writing = $1/7
+1/7$ was just a restatement of that problem. Their answer to
this problem was:
2 shared between 7 :
or
alternatively
there are also other answers, can you find any?
You may have questions of your own you'd like to investigate
about this fraction system.
Some questions which occured to us:
- Can every fraction be written as an Egyptian fraction
sum?
- Is there a method which will guarantee to find an Egyptian
fraction sum every time?
- Does every fraction have more than one possible Egyptian
fraction sum?
- How can I know whether I have found the shortest Egyptian
fraction sum possible?
- The ancient Egyptians lived thousands of years ago, how do
we know what they thought about numbers?
A little research on this topic will show that famous
mathematicians have asked and answered questions about the
Egyptian fraction system for hundreds of years. I quickly found
references to results in this field proved in the 1200s and in
the 2000s. I also found some open questions - things
mathematicians think are true, but no-one has thought of how to
prove them yet.
Why not stop reading now, and find various Egyptian fraction
sums for yourself. Can you answer any of your own questions, or
the ones above?
... or try one of the following:
Fibonacci's greedy algorithm
At every stage, write down
the biggest possible unitary fraction that is less than the
fraction you're working on.
Does this work?
Does it always find the shortest possible sum?
Does the method always work - do the sums always finish? Can
you prove this?
Why is it called a greedy algorithm? - what do these words mean
in a mathematical context?
Formulae for $1/n$ and $2/n$
It is likely that the Egyptians developed specific methods for
converting one of their fractions (ie numerator=1) into
Egyptian fraction sums. Experiment with this and see what
methods you can find.
The Rhind Mathematical Papyrus is an important historical
source for studying Egyptian fractions - it was probably a
reference sheet, or a lesson sheet and contains Egyptian
fraction sums for all the fractions 2/3, 2/5, 2/7 ...2/101. Why
did they only include the odd ones? Can you find sums for
these? Can you find formulae or methods for these? What else
can you find out about the Rhind Mathematical Papyrus?
$4/n$ and $3/n$
In the 1940s, the mathematiciansPaul
Erdos and Ernst G. Straus conjectured that every fraction with
numerator = 4 can be written as an Egyptian fraction sum with
three terms.
If you have found an example that appears to need more than
three, can you find an alternative sum?
Can you find a reason why it must work, or a counter-example -
the conjecture isn't yet proved. It is proved for $3/n$.
The Eye of Horus
Often it was good enough to use only the
fractions {2,4,8,16,32 and 64} to get a fraction that is close
enought to any specific fraction. Pick some fractions and convert
them to this form of Egyptian fraction. You might like to
research how these particular fractions were written down in
pictorial form.
*There is evidence that the specific fraction $2/3$ was used by
the Egyptians, and $3/4$ sometimes as well. They had special
symbols for these two fractions.
old version:
Did you know that the Egyptians wrote all their fractions using
what we call unit fractions? A unit fraction has $1$ as its
numerator (top number). Here are some examples:
$$\frac{1}{5}, \frac{1}{3}, \frac{1}{2}$$
They expressed all fractions as the sum of unit fractions, but
they weren't allowed to repeat the same unit fraction in the
addition. So we couldn't write:
$$\frac{3}{8} = \frac{1}{8}+\frac{1}{8}+\frac{1}{8}$$
because we've used $\frac{1}{8}$ three times.
However, this would be fine:
$$\frac{3}{8}= \frac{1}{4}+\frac{1}{8}$$
How could the Egyptians write $\frac{3}{4}$? Are
there any other ways?
What is $\frac{2}{3}$ written as the sum of unit
fractions? Again, investigate different ways of doing this.
Find some more fractions (say three or four) which
you can write as the sum of unit fractions.